The Week in Focus: No winners in TA/QF feud

The Week in Focus: No winners in TA/QF feud
By admin


Whatever you think of Alan Joyce, he can never be accused of backing away from a scrap, or from making bold decisions.

Faced with the prospect of endless industrial action by mutinous unions last year, his answer was to ground the entire fleet and bring the dispute to a head.

Such a shock tactic ultimately worked, although it was not without huge risks, both for the business and for Joyce personally in the form of his career.

Now, Joyce has reacted in similarly ruthless fashion over the position taken by Geoff Dixon, the airline’s former chief executive and now chairman of Tourism Australia.

To briefly recap, Dixon is among a number of influential individuals said to be alarmed at the strategic direction of Qantas, with a couple of those individuals – though not Dixon – actively briefing against the airline.

The group has acquired 1.5% of Qantas and has ambitions, so we are led to believe, to scupper the planned tie-up with Emirates.

Qantas is of the firm view that Dixon, as chair of the nation’s tourism body, is out of line by involving himself with such a cabal and promptly terminated all commercial ties with TA, citing Dixon’s untenable conflict of interests.

Qantas “cannot continue to collaborate with an agency whose chairman is a member of a syndicate committed to unravelling Qantas’s structure and direction”, it said.

Whether Joyce and Qantas expected TA to ask Dixon to step down in unclear, but that did not happen. On the contrary, TA has publicly backed its chairman and insisted that all protocols were followed with Dixon excusing himself from any discussions involving Qantas.

TA’s support for Dixon comes in part because it genuinely values what he brings to the table. His experience, contacts and deep knowledge of the international aviation industry has been instrumental in securing airline partnerships around the globe. TA would be loathed to lose such qualities.

In addition, TA fundamentally believes that Qantas has over-reacted and has shot itself in the foot by refusing to work with the agency.

There is no question that withdrawing all financial support from TA was a drastic move. While understandable in one regard, there is a bigger picture and higher stakes at play here that made Qantas’s decision surprising (notwithstanding Joyce’s penchant for dramatic action).

I don’t see what Qantas has gained from its stance. Tourism Australia is more than one individual – albeit that individual is the chairman – and there are countless stakeholders who benefit from the close relationship between the two organisations. Punishing TA and the wider tourism industry seemed an over the top response.

Furthermore, Qantas itself benefits from its partnership with TA. It hasn’t worked with the tourism agency over many years for the good of its health. It sees value in working with the national tourism body, value that will now be lost.

TA has predictably played down the impact of losing the support of Qantas. While acknowledging Qantas as the “largest and highest value marketing partnership”, it represents 6% of the total marketing effort with deals with around 20 other airlines helping to ease the disappointment.

That Qantas is not the be all and end all of Tourism Australia’s marketing may be true.

But Australia’s peak tourism body and flag carrier tearing lumps out of each other is hardly the positive image we want to portray overseas. Consumers may not care – it’s hardly going to put them off travelling to Australia – but the international industry will frown upon such a unsightly feud.

Much is said about the importance of uniting behind one tourism voice – ironically underlined recently in a speech by Geoff Dixon – and here we now have the industry’s two most important players at loggerheads. It’s madness.

It might not be very palatable for Joyce to see TA’s chairman – and his former mentor – disagreeing with his strategy for the airline. But according to Qantas, virtually all shareholders are supportive of the proposed Emirates deal so is this “APA mark II club” as Joyce branded it really such a nuisance?

There are no winners in this saga, only losers. And for the good of everyone, it needs resolving quickly. 

As a senior industry figure said last night, tourism minister Martin Ferguson should haul both Joyce and Dixon into a room and get them to sort it out.

Latest News

  • Cruise

Silversea sets sail on its 2025 World Cruise

Experiential luxury and expedition travel brand, Silversea, has set sail on its 2025 World Cruise, Controtempo, taking guests to 59 destinations over 136 days. The cruise set sail from Tokyo on 13 January and arrives in New York on 29 May 2025. Guests will experience many of the most iconic cities and off-the-beaten-path gems in […]

  • Hotels

Dusit International announces two new hotels in the Philippines

Thailand hotel and property development company Dusit International has strengthened its presence in the Philippines with two new hotels in Mindanao, set to open in late 2029. The company, represented in the Philippines by Dusit Thani Philippines Inc., has signed hotel management agreements with IDC Prime. IDC Prime is a wholly owned subsidiary of Italpinas […]

  • Destinations
  • Hotels

Elite Havens adds luxury new villa to its portfolio

Elite Havens, a premier luxury villa rental and management provider, has added a new villa to its existing portfolio of over 250 villas now available for rent in Phuket, Thailand. The Surin Seaview Villa is a three-storey hillside retreat nestled on the hills of Phuket’s beautiful west coast and offers breathtaking views of the Andaman […]

  • Destinations
  • Events

Lunar New Year celebrations across Asia

As the Lunar New Year approaches, various destinations around Asia have announced the different celebrations they have lined up. Fire show, live band, instrumentalists, and bartenders flair show The Anam Group’s two beachfront resorts in Cam Ranh and Mui Ne will celebrate the most significant time in the Vietnamese calendar, Tet, with a broad spectrum […]

  • Conferences

The Australian Tourism Exchange heads to Brisbane Convention & Exhibition Centre from 27 April

The Australian Tourism Exchange (ATE) will be held at the Brisbane Convention & Exhibition Centre from 27 April to 1 May 2025. Tourism Australia requires all sellers attending the event to submit a front panel graphic with one image representing their business for marketing purposes at ATE25, while Destination NSW requires sellers to submit a […]

  • Appointments
  • News

New acting CEO of Destination NSW appointed

Karen Jones has commenced her role as Acting CEO of Destination NSW, taking the reins for an interim period of approximately six months. During this time, the Department of Creative Industries, Tourism, Hospitality and Sport will recruit for a permanent CEO. Jones brings over 27 years of leadership experience in state and local government. Most […]