Court told assumption Ruby Princess was COVID-free was “very stupid”
A judge has been told that embarking on the Ruby Princess at the beginning of the pandemic with the assumption that it was COVID-free was “very stupid.”
Susan Karpik, a former nurse and the lead plaintiff in a class action against Carnival, gave evidence in Federal Court on Monday where she said she was very naive in expecting the Ruby Princess to be COVID-free before the cruise left Sydney on 8 March 2020.
“We had assumed there was no coronavirus on that ship when we boarded … and I recognise now it was probably very stupid now of us to have that view,” Karpik told Justice Angus Stewart.
Kaprik said that at the time, she expected Princess Cruises to be on top of the COVID situation, either cancelling the cruise if the virus was detected or giving passengers the option to leave. She is seeking damages and alleging Princess failed in its responsibility to take reasonable care of its passengers. Carnival has said it will defend against these claims in court.
Kaprik’s claim revolves around her husband, Henry, who had to be placed in a four-week coma and provided ongoing care after contracting COVID.
Of the 1,679 Australians onboard the ship, 663 recorded positive COVID cases and 28 died.
Kaprik’s husband tested positive for influenza A while on board, but wasn’t tested for COVID, she told the court.
“He asked the ship’s doctor if he could be tested and she said that the tests were not available, the helicopter hadn’t dropped them off yet,” Kaprik said.
When the ship returned to Sydney on 19 March 2020, the couple returned home. Henry was admitted to Wollongong hospital on 21 March and put into an induced coma the following day.
When cross-examined by Princess Cruises’ barrister, David McClure SC, Kaprik mentioned she had discussed COVID with her son-in-law, who is a doctor.
“He actually said that cruise ships from his perspective were Petri dishes and the risk of infection was high for any illness or any condition,” she told the court.
The cross-examination led to a discussion of Princess Cruises’ Diamond Princess, where about 700 passengers became infected with COVID near Japan in February 2020. Kaprik said she expected the cruise line to take extra precautions in light of what had happened with the Diamond Princess.
The court heard that the couple was aware that COVID was fatal and highly contagious. However, Kaprik said she knew that the virus was circulating in the northern hemisphere, but not that 70 people in Australia had caught it and two had died.
Kaprik said she felt Princess Cruises would be “100 per cent cautious” about staff across the globe coming aboard its ship.
“We might have been terribly mistaken, but we felt that the cruise company had an obligation to us as customers that that screening would happen,” Kaprik said.
She told the court that she felt reassured the cruise line was barring travellers who had been to China, Hong Kong or Macau.
When her questioning continued, she admitted there was some risk of catching COVID on the cruise.
“Probably much the same as if we were shopping in a busy shopping centre or whatever. The risk is always there,” Kaprik said.
The Guardian reported that she later backtracked on this claim, saying she wasn’t sure if it was in regard to influenza or gastro. Kaprik emphasised she had not seen any risk of catching COVID on the cruise before getting on the ship.
The hearing continues.
Email the Travel Weekly team at traveldesk@travelweekly.com.au
carnival David McClure SC princess cruises Ruby Princess Susan KarpikLatest News
‘I’ve loved it!’ Club Med’s first Home Based Agent conference a winner across the park
A great week in Bali with Club Med. All we can say is we are looking forward to the next one!
Scoot announces new destinations with services commencing from December 2024
We've been talking destination duplication for an age now, and here is a cheap way to try a new tropical paradise.
Virtuoso unveils the Luxe Report | How the affluent are travelling in 2025
We hope the future of luxury travel has us in it somewhere... actually anywhere will do.
Virgin’s new inflight food and drink fiesta – including margaritas!
Is there a round trip where you can try several menu items in a row? Just asking?
Accor signs 27 new hotels in Asia, brings total to 495
Accor has accelerated its growth in Asia securing 27 hotel signings. The expansion encompasses twelve brands throughout eight countries, from India to South Korea and Japan and brings Accors total in the region to 495. The premium, midscale, and economy (PM&E) segments remain central to the Group’s strategic growth plan. Leading the way are the […]
TravelWorks at the forefront of modern day travel management solutions
Not interested in making the change? North Shore Travel boss Sam Young hasn't looked back since he did!
Volcanic activity grounds Bali-Bound Flights as ash and smoke ‘blankets sky’
Travellers headed to Bali have been forced to put plans on hold as volcanic activity continues on Mount Lewotobi Laki-Laki. Multiple flights to the hotspot have been cancelled with Jetstar and Virgin Australia the most impacted. The volcano, located in Indonesia’s Nusa Tenggara province has experienced multiple eruptions in recent days causing thick black ash […]
Inside Travel Group: The B-Corp Certified adventure specialist putting agents first
Whilst a lot of tour operators claim to be ‘people first’, they don’t all live up to the mantle. A tour provider that does, is Inside Travel Group. Not only is Inside Travel Group, which owns InsideJapan and InsideAsia, one of only 13 B-Corp Certified travel companies in Australia, but it also has a 98 […]
Eurostar celebrates three decades of rail with 30% off flash sale
One percent discount for every year... One can only guess what the sale will be when Eurostar hits 100!
Scenic Hotel Group appoints Brett Inkster as property development manager
Scenic Hotel Group has appointed Brett Inkster to the role of property development manager – Pacific Islands. A respected senior manager within Scenic Hotels for the past 25 years, Inkster has successfully supported initiatives to enhance operational efficiencies and foster strategic growth in leadership roles across the group’s properties in New Zealand and the Pacific […]
ATIA urges immediate action on aviation reforms in Senate Inquiry
The Australian Travel Industry Association (ATIA) today appeared before the Senate Committee Inquiry to press for immediate action on critical aviation reforms. The Inquiry is evaluating proposed new laws to implement long-overdue changes to Sydney Airport’s slot-management system aimed at delivering greater reliability, transparency and consumer benefits. These changes represent the most comprehensive reform of […]
Gold Coast to see debut of esteemed Mondrian hotel brand in Australia next year
Beach views, wellness offerings and a dreamy balcony pool. Yep, this one screams Gold Coast!
‘When you wish upon a star’ – Family of 4 rescued by Disney cruise ship
For a brand built upon tales of heroes and princesses, this news story seems all the more fitting.
Rendezvous Hotel Perth Scarborough announces a summer glow-up
It's all happening in WA. If it wasn't so far away we'd have been there a few times this year to see for ourselves.
Qantas announces 72-hour sale to over 60 destinations across Australia
Nothing like a flash sale. Even if you don't have the money or the leave right now, you can still dream!
Qatar Airways continues IRONMAN support with Melbourne race
We were going to participate in the Ironman but sadly we were busy not participating.
Brand USA launches sports-themed famil incentive
This sounds like a pretty cool trip - time to start brushing up on your knowledge of the US.
CATO names Graham ‘Skroo’ Turner as guest speaker at 2024 Christmas Lunch
We imagine Skroo would be a pretty great Christmas lunch guest. Sort of like the uncle who doesn't mince his words.
InterContinental Hayman Island Resort has a new name
Okay spoiler alert for anyone clutching their pearls. The new name isn't that different.
OPINION: Dennis Bunnik – ‘Politicians from both sides have been gorging at the Qantas trough for years’
Dennis certainly has a way with words! An insightful piece from someone who knows the travel industry inside out.
Flight Centre Corporate welcomes REX’s $80m government loan
Flight Centre management are happy about this news. Although not as happy as REX management, we imagine.
To get the most out of France, take the Back-Roads
Just in case you needed more reasons to extend your visit to Europe in 2025, this is it!
CLIA Live tour grows to 8 cities in 2025
Forget Coldplay, this is the kind of tour that gets us TW journos excited!
Bullo River Station partners with Sibella Court for 2026 refurb
If Sibella has anytime leftover after this, our dining room could do with a bit of a spruce up.
REVIEW: Business Class – Sydney to Manila on Philippine Airlines, delivered with Filipino warmth
Hats off to all of the air stewards and stewardesses who manage to stay warm, calm and collected whilst in the air.
WATCH: Club Med successfully wraps inaugural Home Based Agent Conference in Bali
Between the seemingly endless meals at the buffet or Piña coladas by the Zen Pool, we did in fact get some work done!
GALLERY: Intrepid celebrates 35th birthday
We can't tell if it is part of the experience or if there was genuine water on the floor in these pics...
Network 7’s Sam Mac broadcasts his weather live from South Africa
We are just hoping he doesn't end up on one of those blooper reels, not having paid attention to what's behind him.
PONANT grows commercial team with Julie Golding returning
We can't return to our previous employer because we stole all of the staplers and got too drunk at our leaving do.
Intrepid and Lucinda Light launch Daintree travel experience
You can't have the name 'Lucinda Light' and not be a ray of positivity, that would be criminal.
Qatar Airways invites Sydney Swans to Doha to check out high-performance sporting facilities
We know the boys are probably still sweating after their shock GF 2024 loss, but bring on season 2025.
The Curated Plate food and drink festival appoints Peter Kuruvita as creative director
If you want to make your life feel fancier then we recommend trying to lay your food out nicer like the ones in this pic.
Oceanview Helicopters launches Picnic on a Peak on the Sunshine Coast tour
After reading this article we have a deep and serious craving for Chorizo.
ATAC Conference wrap: A taste of bigger things to come
These guys had the right mix when it came to information, education and celebration. Plus the food was good too.
Tourism Australia MD Phillipa Harrison and cricketer David Warner head to India
Apparently, the Australian cricket team was short on players and Harrison and Warner were the first to volunteer.
Carnival commits to Queensland as Luminosa kicks off third season homeporting from BNE
The summer cruise season is well and truly underway and we couldn't be more excited!